What’s the Issue with Floating Bus Stops?

A guest post from Cllr John Morris, who represents Canning Town South in Newham and is former Deputy Cabinet Member for Highways and Sustainable Transport. He writes at The Plaistovian.

The current road safety debate about bus stop bypasses (BSBs) may seem arcane. But the row threatens to derail progress to make cycling safer while failing to improve road safety for blind people.

It’s a very British row. At a cycling event in Europe, an Oslo policy advisor showed a photo of a Norwegian floating bus stop and joked, “I heard these are quite controversial here”. Floating bus stops have been common across Europe for decades.

In the UK, the debate about them has become polarised, but as usual, we’ve had similar arguments before, and those previous rows about zebra crossings are now forgotten while everyone accepts them.

What is a bus-stop-bypass?

There are two designs.

  • A shared-use bus border (SUBB), is where a cycle lane runs between the shelter and the kerb, through the boarding area
  • A bus stop bypass (BSB), the cycle lane runs behind a boarding island.
A Shared Use Bus Border
A Shared Use Bus Border

BSBs are the better design because they keep passengers apart from the cycle track and have a defined crossing. SUBBs are far from ideal and only suit narrow roads. The guidance from the Department for Transport recommends BSBs.

Why do we need bus-stop bypasses?

They solve two problems at once, a safety one and a behavioural one. On busy main roads, cyclists share space with buses and heavy traffic. That not only is unsafe, but it feels unsafe, so only the bravest people cycle there. Many people, including women, children, older people and disabled people don’t want to dice with buses, cars and lorries. It’s also bad for buses which have to slow down behind cyclists.

Floating bus stop
Floating bus stop (CC0 1.0 DEED/RawPixel public domain)

Putting in a separated cycle lane makes the roads safer for cyclists, but creates a different problem. Every time cycle lanes meet a bus stop they stop, so cyclists are pushed out into the middle of the road and conflict returns.

The solution is floating bus stops, which removes the conflict between cyclists and vehicles and opens up the chance for more risk-adverse people to start cycling.

What’s the problem with them?

The controversy is that pedestrians must cross the cycle lane to reach the bus island. If cyclists don’t stop, pedestrians are put at risk, this is especially serious for blind or visually impaired people who can’t see cyclists coming or judge gaps.

The Highway Code treats BSB zebra crossings as exactly the same as any other zebra crossing. Cyclists should stop if pedestrians are waiting to cross and must stop if pedestrians are already on the crossing. Unfortunately, there’ve been several viral videos showing cyclists failing to stop for pedestrians. This has led to demands by groups such as London TravelWatch for SUBBs to be removed and BSBs to be paused until cyclists learn the Highway Code and stop at the zebra crossings serving these bus stops. The problem is that this will create a barrier to inclusive cycling and sets the bar for success so high it can never be met.

A traditional bus stop
A traditional bus stop

The fears of blind and disabled people are understandable, but the data doesn’t support those concerns. TfL published a safety review of all 164 bus stop bypasses in London in November 2026. Over three years it found just five pedestrian casualties involving cyclists, plus one involving an e-scooter. For comparison, 11,400 pedestrians were injured by motor vehicles in London over that same period. The threat to road safety for all pedestrians is still from cars.

We’ve been here before

My point is that while seeing cyclists flow past a floating bus stop without stopping for pedestrians, some of whom are visually impaired, is distressing, the answer is not to stop building them. The road safety charity Living Streets notes that the “give way” culture embedded in the Netherlands and Denmark happens because cycling is far more common there.

Zebra crossings make an excellent comparison, they took years to work in the UK. When they were first introduced no-one knew how to use them. Early versions only had studs in the road as well as Belisha Beacons and the design changed iteratively with low compliance until the 1950s, when the zebra crossing reached its current design, but even then, only after a national enforcement and information campaign.

It’s the same with BSB’s, cyclists and pedestrians need to see or experience how they’re meant to behave around them, which only happens either by watching their peers stop at the zebra crossing and following their lead, or by being physically stopped and held to account by a police officer for not obeying the Highway Code.

But how can you enforce something that for many doesn’t exist. You can’t enforce a rule for a piece of infrastructure that many cyclists have never encountered, and floating bus stops are still mostly in London. So to make them work across the country, build them first, as with zebra crossings, then educate and enforce.

Steps to solve the immediate problem

There are things we can do now. The police can, and should, enforce the highway code on zebra crossings at floating bus stops. DfT itself noted that designs vary and signage could be improved. Even the original zebra crossings evolved from metal studs to painted stripes to increase compliance.
Zebra crossings show the way:

  • Build good infrastructure nationally.
  • Add signage that makes priority obvious.
  • Enforce the Highway Code.
  • Once there are enough of them, run an education campaign.

The answer to a real problem with floating bus stops isn’t to abandon them. It’s to make them work.


Discover more from Labour Walks and Cycles

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply